Forrest's Pizza

Discover Forrest's Pizza in Silver City, NM, offering authentic New York-style pizza, delicious pizza by the slice, garlic knots, and fresh toppings. Enjoy outdoor seating and our signature pies like Popeye and spinach & artichoke. Call +1 575-388-1225 for takeaway!

Welcome to Forrest's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Forrest's Pizza
Forrest's Pizza
Forrest's Pizza
Forrest's Pizza

Forrest's Pizza serves authentic New York style pizza right in the heart of Silver City, NM. Located at 601 N Bullard St J, this takeaway hotspot is known for its chewy crust and fresh toppings, appealing to locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving a classic slice or something unique like the Popeye pizza with spinach and artichokes, Forrest's Pizza has something for every palate.

The ambiance blends casual charm with community spirit, making it an ideal stop for a quick lunch or a laid-back dinner. On busy Saturdays, the energy fills the air as families and friends gather to enjoy their favorite pies, especially during peak hours. You won't just grab a slice; you’ll soak in the vibrant local culture buzz. This is where flavor meets community.

Location & Contact

Address

601 N Bullard St J, Silver City, NM 88061, United States

Phone

+1 575-388-1225

Social Media

About

Forrest's Pizza
Forrest's Pizza
Forrest's Pizza
Forrest's Pizza

Forrest's Pizza's story begins with a passion for New York style pizza that transcends geographic boundaries. Offering a warm welcome to everyone who walks through the door, this pizza takeaway makes it easy to enjoy quality Italian cuisine in a relaxed environment. Each slice tells its own story, crafted with care and quality ingredients sourced whenever possible from local suppliers. The menu includes classic offerings alongside creative combinations, allowing guests to dive into a unique flavor adventure.

Popular items like spinach and artichoke pizza highlight the kitchen’s creativity, catering to diverse tastes. The cheery staff complements the unbeatable flavors with top-notch service, often engaging with customers as they prepare orders. The cozy ambiance inside combines warmth and casual vibes, making patrons feel at home. Whether stopping by for a quick slice or grabbing a whole pie to share, Forrest's Pizza embodies the spirit of community.

It reflects the melting pot of cultures that Silver City represents, forging connections with each meal shared. The local vibe fosters camaraderie among diners, creating a sense of belonging that keeps patrons returning for more.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Forrest's Pizza proudly offers a range of delicious options that go beyond traditional pizza. With 10 distinctive dishes, including specialty pizzas like The Angels and the Hawaii Five-O, there's plenty to explore. The selection doesn’t stop at pizza; guests can indulge in freshly made salads dressed in house recipes. The popular garlic knots serve as an excellent side, adding to the overall dining experience. For those on the go, options for pizza by the slice make it easy to satisfy cravings without skipping a beat.

The outdoor seating area invites diners to relish their food under the New Mexico sky, fostering a sense of community as people gather. While weekends may get busy, the staff ensures quick service without compromising quality. This variety and commitment to delivering fantastic food make Forrest's Pizza a beloved local gem.

Forrest's Pizza

Forrest's Pizza stands out with its inviting exterior on N Bullard St. The combination of rustic charm and a vibrant outdoor area draws in diners searching for great food and conversation. The outdoor seating allows guests to enjoy their meals while soaking in the relaxed atmosphere of Silver City. On pleasant days, the lively chatter of customers fills the space, creating an engaging community experience.

The overall vibe makes it a perfect spot to relax with friends and family or even meet fellow pizza enthusiasts stopping by. Today, as they dig into a slice, they cultivate connections that go beyond food, reinforcing the camaraderie of local dining.

Customer Reviews

I happily drive an hour and a half to get pizza here! The quality is always excellent. You can build your own pizza or try one of their creative and delicious specialty pies. There is no inside seating but plenty of room outside which is perfect on a beautiful day. The friendly service is also top notch! This place is worth it every time

J
Jeremy S.

14" half sausage pie little extra sauce well done. 14" Marilyn add fresh garlic well dome. This pizza is top notch!!! If anyone in silver goes anywhere else for a New York style pizza they are absolutely nuts. Great job guys!!! Keep the love in them pies!!!

D
Dominick A.

After the drive from Gila National Monument, I was hungry so I stopped at Silver City before heading back to El Paso. Came across this pizza place and ordered the Hawaiian pizza since I'm from Hawaii and want to try the pizza that matches where I came from . No disappoint it taste very good. Didn't mind the wait because a lot of people were ordering and waiting so I know this place is gonna be good. Shoutout to my hiking friend who recommend me this spot to eat at.

J
Jerome A.

Small but user friendly. Placed an order and bought a chainsaw down the street. By the time I finished up with the chain saw my pizza was done. Give them people a raise. Just keep the pizza the same pls

B
Brandon A.

July 2025: Still the best pizza in town...not the cheapest by far, but very high quality! Try the Tombstone! Summer 2024: Best pizza in Silver City! Yes, their prices have gone up more than once during the time we've been eating Forrest's. For a minute it felt too expensive, but the pizza however is almost always perfectly on point with thin crust and fresh, delicious toppings. The Kim's Favorite (alfredo sauce, spinach, artichoke hearts, and fresh garlic) is our...favorite! FYI no indoor seating. Local love.

P
Phoenix M.

Stopped by to grab a pizza on the way home after a long day. Grabbed a large pepperoni and ricotta with a house salad. Absolutely amazing. Perfect chewy/crispy thin crust, bright tomato flavor, savory pepperoni and no shortage of creamy ricotta. This pizza is a must try. Don't be intimidated by it's size, leftovers reheat amazingly. Worth every penny!

C
Chrystal M.